By AR Digital, web and marketing agency in Luxembourg. Updated on 9 September 2026.
Since 28 May 2022, European Directive 2019/2161 has banned buying, selling or publishing fake reviews, and requires you to explain how your reviews are collected. Google meanwhile removes hundreds of millions of reviews every year. Six common practices now expose Luxembourg SMEs.
Reviews are no longer a marketing matter, but a compliance one
For years, customer reviews were treated as a communication topic. You wanted plenty of them, you wanted good ones, and that was the end of the question. This is no longer the framework a Luxembourg business works in.
Two developments have come together. On one side, Directive (EU) 2019/2161, applicable since 28 May 2022, bans the sale, purchase and submission of fake consumer reviews for promotional purposes, and requires you to inform the public about how reviews are handled. On the other, platforms have industrialised detection.
The question is therefore no longer whether your rating is good, but whether the way you obtain your reviews would withstand an inspection, or simply a competitor’s report. In Luxembourg, this falls under the rules on unfair commercial practices described by Guichet.lu (in French).
What the European text says exactly
The directive does not ask you to check every review one by one. It asks you not to fabricate or buy reviews, and to be able to explain publicly how you collect them, how you make sure they come from real customers, and whether any reward is given. It is an obligation of transparency about the method, not about the result.
The 6 practices that expose your SME
Here are the six most common situations among SMEs in the Greater Region. None of them is exotic, and several are even presented as good practice by some providers.
1. Offering a reward in exchange for a review
A discount, a free coffee, a voucher, entry into a prize draw. Google’s user-generated content policy (in French) bans exchanging a reward for a review, whatever form it takes. On the European side, a review obtained in return for payment must at the very least be identified as such. The loyalty card conditional on a five-star review remains the most widespread and most exposed practice.
2. Only asking happy customers
This is filtering upstream: an internal questionnaire sorts your customers, and only the satisfied ones receive the link to your profile. The rating you get then does not reflect the reality of your customer base. The method is presented as clever, but it is in fact misleading within the meaning of the directive on unfair commercial practices, and Google treats it as rating manipulation.
3. Buying reviews, or using an intermediary who sells them
This is the clearest point legally, and yet it is still going on. A pack of purchased reviews leaves obvious traces: recent accounts, an abnormal pace, similar wording. That is exactly what detection systems look for.
4. Having reviews written internally
Employees, partners, family, close network. These reviews match no real customer experience, which is enough to make them non-compliant with Google’s rules. The organised variant, which consists of asking each team member to get their relatives to post reviews, produces the kind of contribution pattern that the systems pick up.
5. Publishing reviews on your website without explaining where they come from
Testimonials on the home page are covered just like your Google profile. If your website displays stars or an average, you must be able to say how these reviews are collected and verified. This is the point on which most of the European websites inspected were found at fault.
6. Replying by disclosing information about the customer
Faced with an unfair review, the temptation is to set the record straight: the invoice amount, the date of the visit, the nature of the service. You then expose personal data in a public space, which falls under the GDPR. A public reply sticks to the principle and never goes into the case file.
The quick test. Take your last twenty reviews. For each one, can you name the customer and the service concerned without consulting anyone? If the answer is no for more than two of them, your collection method deserves a review.
What Google already blocks, with figures
This is not a theoretical question. In its report published on 16 April 2026, Google states that it blocked or removed more than 292 million reviews that broke its policies in 2025, while publishing more than a billion reviews judged useful.
| Action taken by Google in 2025 | Volume announced |
|---|---|
| Reviews blocked or removed for breaking the policies | More than 292 million |
| Profile edits blocked as inaccurate or unverified | 79 million |
| Accounts subject to posting restrictions | More than 782,000 |
| Fake business profiles removed | More than 13 million |
Source: Google, 2025 Trust and Safety report, published on 16 April 2026.
Two consequences for an SME. First, a campaign of artificial reviews is not only ineffective: it can be reversed after the fact, which makes a rating built on that basis collapse. Second, Google states that when a spike of suspicious reviews is detected, the posting of new reviews can be suspended on the profile and a banner shown to internet users. The damage becomes visible to your customers.
The fake one-star review scam
The same report documents a practice that affects shops and self-employed professionals: the deliberate posting of fake negative reviews, followed by a request for payment to have them removed. Google says it has strengthened detection of this scheme to block these posts before they go live.
The right course of action never involves paying. Report the reviews through your business profile, document the sequence with timestamped screenshots, do not reply to the blackmailer, and respond publicly in a neutral way. A calm reply protects your image better than a perfect rating.
The reflex that makes things worse
Offsetting a wave of negative reviews with positive ones ordered in a hurry. You add an abnormal pattern to a profile that has already been reported, and you risk losing the genuine reviews built up over years.
Collecting reviews within the rules
Compliance and effectiveness point the same way here. Asking for a review is not forbidden, and never has been. What is forbidden is steering, sorting or paying.
- Ask everyone, with no prior filter. A regular flow of sincere reviews, including a few average ones, is more credible than an unbroken run of five stars.
- Ask at the right moment, just after delivery or the visit.
- Make it easy without influencing. A link to your profile is legitimate. A suggested wording is not.
- Attach no conditions. No benefit, no discount, no prize draw in exchange.
- Reply to every review, without ever disclosing personal information.
- Keep a record of your method, so you can describe it if you are asked.
This regularity also serves your visibility: reviews feed local SEO, and an active profile carries weight in location-based results. It is long-term work, just like your SEO, and it is built over months.
What your website must say about your reviews
This is the point most often forgotten, and the easiest to fix. In 2022, the European Commission and the authorities of 26 Member States screened 223 websites. The results are instructive for any SME that displays testimonials.
| Finding of the European check on 223 websites | Number of websites concerned |
|---|---|
| Authenticity of reviews not confirmed by the authorities | 144 |
| No information on how reviews are collected and processed | 104 |
| No information on preventing misleading reviews | 118 |
| No mention of the status of reviews encouraged by a reward | 176 |
Source: European Commission, results of the coordinated check published on 20 January 2022.
Overall, the authorities concluded that at least 55% of the websites checked potentially infringed the directive on unfair commercial practices, with doubts about a further 18%. These were not marginal players, but large online shops, marketplaces and booking sites.
The fix comes down to one paragraph added near your testimonials. It states who can leave a review, how you check that they are a customer, whether you give any reward, and what you do with negative reviews. A few honest lines are enough to set you apart from most of the websites checked. If your website is being redesigned or built, now is the time to include it.
To check with your providers. If a review collection tool, a CRM or an agency runs this process for you, ask in writing how requests are sent, to which customers, and whether any sorting is applied. The responsibility remains yours, not the tool’s. A question to ask before you choose a provider (in French).
Frequently asked questions
Can I ask my customers for a review?
Yes, without reservation. Asking for feedback is legitimate and is forbidden neither by European law nor by Google’s rules. What is forbidden is making that request conditional on a reward, sending it only to satisfied customers, or suggesting the content of the review.
Can an unhappy customer demand that their review be deleted?
Its author can edit or delete it at any time. You cannot: you can only report it to Google if it breaks the platform’s rules, for example if it is defamatory or off topic.
What should I do about a negative review that matches no real customer?
Report it from your business profile, then reply publicly in a neutral way, saying that you cannot find a matching file. Keep your screenshots, and never pay for a removal.
Are the reviews shown on my own website subject to the same rules?
Yes. The transparency obligation applies to the reviews you publish, whatever the medium. A carousel of testimonials on your home page must be explainable: origin, collection method, any rewards.
Is a Luxembourg business with Belgian or French customers affected twice?
The framework comes from European law, so it is common to all three countries, with separate national enforcement authorities. For an SME active in the Greater Region, the practical rule is to align with the strictest requirement.
How many reviews should I aim for to be credible?
There is no regulatory threshold, and chasing a number encourages bad practice. Regularity matters more: a few reviews every month over two years inspire more trust than a profile that collected fifty in a week.
Sources
- European Commission, Representation in Luxembourg, results of the coordinated check on online reviews, 20 January 2022 (in French)
- Official Journal of the European Union, Directive (EU) 2019/2161 of 27 November 2019, applicable since 28 May 2022
- Google, 2025 Trust and Safety report for Maps, published on 16 April 2026
- Google, policy on user-generated content (in French)
- Guichet.lu, identifying an unfair commercial practice, Luxembourg (in French)









