Skip to content

AR Digital / Blog/Websites

Cookies and GDPR in Luxembourg: the 6 mistakes that expose your SME to the CNPD and break your Google campaigns

A non-compliant cookie banner in Luxembourg means CNPD risk and lost Google conversions. The 6 most common mistakes and how to fix them.

Radu UleaFounder of AR Digital

8 min read

Privacy policy concept illustrating cookie and GDPR compliance for an SME in Luxembourg

A poorly configured cookie banner doesn’t just cost you a potential fine. It costs you conversions, every day, without anyone noticing.

In Luxembourg, a cookie banner must collect free and explicit consent before any non-essential tracker, provide information on two levels and pass that choice on to your advertising tools. When that last link is missing, the CNPD can impose sanctions and Google stops measuring your conversions properly.

The National Commission for Data Protection published its guidelines on cookies and other trackers (in French) in October 2021. This document remains the reference in Luxembourg, and it is considerably more demanding than what most SME websites apply.

The reasoning rests on a simple distinction. A tracker that is strictly necessary for the service to work, for example a shop’s basket or the login session, does not require consent. Everything else, commercial audience measurement, advertising, sharing buttons, embedded videos, maps, instant messaging, requires consent obtained before the tracker is set.

The CNPD also specifies the form. Information must be provided on two levels: a first short, readable message, then a second level detailing each tracker, its purpose, its retention period and the entity responsible. Consent must result from a clear positive action, which rules out pre-ticked boxes. The European Data Protection Board’s Guidelines 03/2022 on deceptive design patterns, consolidated in 2023, describe the practices that invalidate consent.

The point everyone misses

The CNPD reminds us that the website operator remains responsible for compliance even when using a consent management platform supplied by a third party.

Installing a plugin therefore transfers no responsibility: if the module is badly configured, your company is the one that answers for it.

The 6 most common mistakes on SME websites

1. Trackers fire before the visitor has made a choice

This is by far the most widespread failing, and the most invisible to a business owner. The banner displays correctly, but the measurement and advertising tags have already run when the page loads. Consent becomes purely decorative. The test is immediate: open your site in a private window, then open the browser’s developer tools, and check whether any requests go out to third-party domains before the first click.

2. Refusing takes more effort than accepting

A clearly visible “Accept all” button, and a refusal hidden behind “Customise”, then three screens of settings. This imbalance is exactly the type of practice targeted by the European guidelines on deceptive design. Consent obtained this way is fragile: if challenged, it doesn’t hold up, and all the data collection based on it becomes unlawful.

The wording “by continuing to browse, you accept our cookies” no longer has any legal value. Neither do pre-ticked boxes. The CNPD is explicit: consent requires a positive action by the visitor. Yet this wording lingers on many Luxembourg websites built before 2020 and never revisited since.

4. The second level of information is missing or empty

Many banners settle for three generous categories: necessary, statistics, marketing. The CNPD expects more detail, tracker by tracker, with purpose, duration and controller. This is not cosmetic: it is the level that a complainant or an inspector looks at first, because it shows whether the inventory was really carried out.

The GDPR requires that withdrawing consent be as easy as giving it. You therefore need a permanent access point, often a link in the footer, that reopens the choices panel. On most brochure websites, there is none: once the banner has been accepted, the visitor has no way of going back.

6. The visitor’s choice is never passed on to Google

This is the costliest mistake, and the only one that shows up in your revenue. The banner collects consent but does not pass it on to Google’s tags. You bear the legal cost of compliance without reaping the commercial benefit.

Mistake What it breaks Fix
Trackers fired before consent Unlawful collection across all traffic Prior blocking at the tag manager level
Refusing is harder than accepting Consent open to challenge Two buttons of equal prominence on the first screen
Assumed consent No legal basis Positive action required, no pre-ticked boxes
Second level of information missing Demonstrable failure to inform Complete inventory: purpose, duration, controller
Withdrawal impossible Breach of Article 7 of the GDPR Permanent access point in the footer
Consent not passed on to Google Degraded conversion measurement and remarketing Consent Mode correctly wired

Since March 2024, Google requires advertisers serving the European Economic Area, the United Kingdom and Switzerland to pass consent choices on to it. The Google Ads documentation on changes to Consent Mode describes four signals: advertising storage, analytics storage, use of data for advertising purposes and ad personalisation.

When these signals don’t come through, things degrade in stages. Conversion measurement loses its reliability, so automated bidding steers blind. Remarketing audiences stop filling up. You keep paying for your clicks at the same price, but the algorithm meant to make them profitable works with no feedback.

The opposite trap exists too. Google states in its documentation that if you completely block its tags from loading until the visitor has interacted with the banner, it can no longer verify consent choices, which also leads to data loss. The solution is not to block everything, but to load the tags in a denied state by default, then unlock them according to the visitor’s answer.

This is why we treat cookie compliance and advertising tracking as a single project. Separating the two always produces one of two failures: a compliant site that no longer measures anything, or a site that measures everything and shouldn’t. If you invest in paid search campaigns, this wiring determines the return on your media budget.

What a Luxembourg business really risks

Article 83 of the GDPR provides for fines of up to EUR 20 million or 4% of annual worldwide turnover, whichever is higher. This ceiling targets the most serious breaches and is obviously not the typical scenario for an SME of twenty people. It does, however, set the order of magnitude of the CNPD’s power to sanction, which can act under the GDPR as well as national law.

In practice, the most common trigger is not a spontaneous inspection but a complaint, filed by a visitor, a former employee or an attentive competitor. The procedure starts with a request for explanations, and that is where the lack of an inventory becomes a concrete problem: you have to document in a few weeks what has never been documented.

A second risk weighs more heavily in Luxembourg, given the weight of the financial sector and business services. Supplier compliance questionnaires now almost always include questions on data processing. A faulty banner on your own site then becomes a negative signal at the very moment you are trying to win a large account.

In what order to fix things, and who does it

The order matters: each step depends on the previous one. A team that installs a consent module before inventorying its trackers always ends up doing the work twice.

  1. Inventory the trackers that are actually present. Not the ones you think you have, the ones that fire. Plugins accumulated over the years often set forgotten trackers.
  2. Classify each tracker as essential or non-essential, and document purpose, duration and controller. This list will feed the second level of information.
  3. Choose a consent platform that is compatible with Google’s requirements, configured so that refusing is as accessible as accepting.
  4. Wire the passing of consent to the tags, in a denied state by default, then check signal by signal in preview mode.
  5. Update the privacy policy so that it matches the real inventory, not a generic template.
  6. Keep proof of consents and plan a periodic recheck.

Indicative order of magnitude: on an SME brochure website, this work is generally done in a few days. The workload depends on the number of accumulated trackers and the quality of the technical base, and remains to be adjusted after the inventory.

A note on method, applied to all our custom website projects: the banner must exist in every language the site is published in. On a site in French, German and English, a panel in French only weakens the case that the information was understood. In Luxembourg, this point comes up more often than elsewhere.

Finally, if the compliance work is part of a wider redesign, it may fall within the scope of a subsidised project. Our page on SME Packages Digital and the 70% grant details the eligibility conditions.

Frequently asked questions

Only those strictly necessary for the requested service: login session, basket, security, load balancing, language memory. The CNPD recommends informing visitors of their presence, but no consent is required.

Who is responsible if the banner comes from an external tool?

You are. The CNPD states that the site operator remains responsible even when using a consent management platform supplied by a third party. Choosing and configuring the module is up to you.

Does a brochure website with no advertising also need a banner?

Yes, as soon as it embeds commercial audience measurement, a video hosted elsewhere, a map, a messaging tool or a social network button. These integrations set third-party trackers, even without a campaign.

It still receives modelled data, but measurement loses accuracy and advertising uses are restricted. Google requires consent choices to be passed on for European Economic Area traffic, and the degradation mainly affects conversions and audiences.

The trackers concerned stop collecting and cookies already set must be deleted. On the advertising side, signals go back to a denied state. Hence the importance of the permanent access point: without it, withdrawal is technically impossible.

How often should the tracker inventory be redone?

Every new plugin, every marketing integration and every theme change can introduce an undeclared tracker. We recommend a recheck after every significant change to the site, and at least once a year.

Sources

ShareLinkedInBy email

Radu UleaFounder of AR Digital

Founder of AR Digital, a web and digital marketing agency in Luxembourg. He helps SME owners with their website, visibility, advertising and move to artificial intelligence, and writes the Daily AI edition every working day. LinkedIn

70%SME Packages

The State funds up to 70% of this project.

With Luxinnovation’s SME Packages, up to 17,500 EUR in grants. AR Digital is an official provider: we check your eligibility for free and build the application with you.

AR Digital / Contact

Let’s talk about your project.

Thirty minutes, by video call or at the agency, to understand what you need and tell you frankly what we would do, at what price and with what funding. No commitment.

Radu Ulea, founder of AR Digital

Radu Ulea

Founder, AR Digital

“We tell you what works, what doesn’t, and what it costs. Then we do it.”

hello@ardigital.eu